• Home
  • About Us
  • Our Story
  • Products
    • Permacure CCA
    • Permacure ACQ
    • Permabore Boron
    • Waterguard Wax
    • Close
  • Services
  • Digital Solutions
    • Digital Tools
    • Close
  • Contact Us
  • search icon
    • Close
  • Dolphin Bay white icon
  • GET IN TOUCH
  • CUSTOMER APPLICATION FORM
Menu
  • dolphin bay icon
  • CCA treated timber iconPermacure CCA
  • acq preservativesPermacure ACQ
  • Dolphin Bay ServicesServices
  • Dolphin Bay NewsNews
  • Dolphin Bay NewsNewsletters
  • pressMedia
  • OurBlogOur Blog
  • Dolphin Bay logo
Aug 01

CONCERNS AND CONFUSION AS CARBON TAX KICKS IN

  • August 1, 2019

The Carbon Tax came into effect on 01 June 2019, amid a flurry of confusion and controversy for the forestry, sawmilling, and timber-treatment industries.

“The National Treasury has done this incorrectly,” says Michael Peter of Forestry South Africa. “The thinking and methodology are flawed, and the fact that they have botched it so badly, given our many inputs into the process over several years, is a real surprise to everybody. It’s a mess.”

The tax applies immediately to all processing industries that conduct activities with the carbon dioxide (CO2) equivalent of greenhouse gas emissions above a total combined capacity threshold of 10 MW (thermal).

It is payable for the tax period June 1 to 31 December this year, and January 1 to 31 December in years to come. There has been no indication from government that the tax revenue will be ring-fenced for climate-change or other environmental projects.

In theory, the tax should not apply to CCA operations where the timber or poles are air-seasoned and treated with CCA at ambient temperatures, says SAWPA Executive Director Bruce Breedt.

 

“Treasury ignored what the industry has been saying and ignored the UN definition.”

 

“Plants that could be liable are those with boilers to heat kilns, creosote etc, when the boiler capacity exceeds the 10 MW threshold,” he explains.

However, the Carbon Tax is causing deep concern in the forestry sector, with the fundamental argument centering on Treasury’s classification of poles, paper, and other timber products as a source of carbon emissions, rather than considering the CO2 that is locked up in those products and classing them as a source of carbon removals.

Michael says: “The United Nations’ Food and Agriculture Organisation recognises the carbon neutrality of biomass, whether from burning or decomposition. At worst, forest products anywhere in the world, even from indigenous forests, should be treated as carbon neutral, as long as the forests are being replanted and sustainably managed.

“Forest products from plantations should enjoy heightened recognition as being carbon positive, as the plantations from which they were harvested did not exist as forests historically. Treasury should either recognise and give credit for the carbon removals in the plantations themselves, or for the products which the plantations produce. The Carbon Tax Act does neither and, worse, actually penalises the industry, as if we were burning fossil fuels.

“It goes even further to say that any loss of plantations to fire, pests, diseases or land-use change, will also be treated as an emission. Treasury ignored what the industry has been saying and ignored the UN definition. It is devoid of any logic and an absolute anathema to us.”

While there is a five-year Carbon Tax exemption period for AFOLU (agriculture, forestry and other land users) industries, Michael believes that timber processors – represented by PAMSA, SAWPA and Sawmilling SA – should lead the petition against the Carbon Tax, as processors are already subject to it.

“We’ve agreed that they need to petition National Treasury to say that there should be no imposition of an emissions tax on processors with respect to products, until such time that Treasury has remedied this fundamental flaw.

“The way the regulation has been written, in five years’ time we will have to first report on our greenhouse gas inventory – what has been sequestered and what has been released – and as long as they balance, we’re OK. But if we have a devastating fire or over-sell in any given year, we will have to pay an emissions tax. We’re saying that’s nonsense, because we sequestered that CO2 in the first place. The Carbon Tax doesn’t recognise that.”

Forestry SA is especially concerned that the Tax has classified plantations and natural forests in the same line. “Plantations are not indigenous, natural forests,” Michael says. “They were originally grasslands. In fact, our forests locked in 13 to 17 times more CO2 than the grasslands they replaced. Therefore, the products we produce should be recognised for their perpetual storage of CO2.”

Bertus shares these widely-held concerns. “The last thing business in South Africa needs is yet another tax, as business is already under severe strain to comply with existing government red tape,” he said. “Companies need to get on with their core business of creating value and jobs, not be increasingly distracted by ever-increasing administrative demands and costs.

“The Carbon Tax is a hollow measure in the light of the government’s own investment into carbon-emitting projects like the coal-fired Medupi and Kusile power stations.”

  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Dolphin Bay Brief
Dolphin Bay Brief
Dolphin Bay is a chemical company specialising in the manufacture of wood preservatives. We are a major market player within the African continent, where our products and services are supplied to reputable companies supplying treated timber to the agricultural, building, electrical and communications industries.
Dolphin Bay Brief
Latest posts by Dolphin Bay Brief (see all)
  • NRCS’ INACTION SPURS ON DANGEROUS CRIMINALS - June 1, 2022
  • CLIENT AGRO-SERVE LAUNCHES OUR NEW DIY TIMBER TREATMENT - June 1, 2022
  • HOW TO BRACE FOR A WORLD RECESSION - June 1, 2022

Comments are closed.

Welcome to Dolphin Bay Brief which delivers the latest news and insights about our sector, related industries and the broader economy in which we operate.

IN OTHER DOLPHIN BAY NEWS

  • MOVING A PULL SCAR PLANT FROM CAPE TOWN TO WHITE RIVER
    MOVING A PULL SCAR PLANT FROM CAPE TOWN TO WHITE RIVER
  • A YEAR OF GREATER RISK, GREATER REWARDS
    A YEAR OF GREATER RISK, GREATER REWARDS
  • WELCOME TO SILVERWOOD, OUR FIRST KENYAN CUSTOMER
    WELCOME TO SILVERWOOD, OUR FIRST KENYAN CUSTOMER
  • DOLPHIN BAY ADDS COPPER AZOLE TO PRODUCT RANGE
    DOLPHIN BAY ADDS COPPER AZOLE TO PRODUCT RANGE
  • AGORA A ‘HIVE OF ACTIVITY’ AFTER AGREEMENT WITH DOLPHIN BAY
    AGORA A ‘HIVE OF ACTIVITY’ AFTER AGREEMENT WITH DOLPHIN BAY
  • WHY GOVERNMENT SHOULD MEND ITS RIFT WITH BUSINESS
    WHY GOVERNMENT SHOULD MEND ITS RIFT WITH BUSINESS
  • SHIPPING CONSTRAINTS AND STORIES: A NOTE FROM THINUS
    SHIPPING CONSTRAINTS AND STORIES: A NOTE FROM THINUS
  • FUTURISTS DESCRIBE “BIGGEST SOCIETAL SHIFT SINCE WW2”
    FUTURISTS DESCRIBE “BIGGEST SOCIETAL SHIFT SINCE WW2”
  • AFRICA’S MASSIVE VARIATIONS IN STANDARDS
    AFRICA’S MASSIVE VARIATIONS IN STANDARDS
  • STRIKING THE BALANCE BETWEEN RISK AND GROWTH
    STRIKING THE BALANCE BETWEEN RISK AND GROWTH

FILTER BY NEWS CATEGORY

  • Our Company
  • Our Customers
  • Our Industry
  • Our Society

Dolphin Bay icon

Dolphin Bay is committed to serving our industry, in order to ensure the growth of your business and ours. We are industry experts, constantly monitoring national and international markets for new trends and developments.

SIGN UP

CONTACT INFO

Voorbaai Crescent, Bayview Industria, Mossel Bay Phone: +27 (0) 44 6951575 E-Mail: info@dolphinbay.co.za Web: www.dolphinbay.co.za

Download a copy of Dolphin Bay’s PAIA Manual

Download Now

Terms and conditions of sale

Download Now

Copyright © Dolphin Bay | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy